{"agreement_rate_2plus":0.6975806451612904,"context":{"global_agreement_rate_2plus":0.24817626916778324,"pairwise_kappa":{"censoredplanet|voidly_probes":{"kappa":-0.1041062565087169,"n":13434,"n_a_only":2993,"n_b_only":1037,"n_both_present":59,"n_neither":9345,"pe":0.7283005049260842,"po":0.7000148875986303},"ioda|censoredplanet":{"kappa":-0.2703011640543201,"n":13434,"n_a_only":6666,"n_b_only":2331,"n_both_present":721,"n_neither":3716,"pe":0.4727875220956278,"po":0.33028137561411347},"ioda|voidly_probes":{"kappa":-0.09059519669756419,"n":13434,"n_a_only":7114,"n_b_only":823,"n_both_present":273,"n_neither":5224,"pe":0.4582643006001429,"po":0.40918564835492033},"ooni|censoredplanet":{"kappa":0.1602806282382945,"n":13434,"n_a_only":3971,"n_b_only":1241,"n_both_present":1811,"n_neither":6411,"pe":0.5379756221501314,"po":0.6120291796933155},"ooni|ioda":{"kappa":-0.529603107378566,"n":13434,"n_a_only":4406,"n_b_only":6011,"n_both_present":1376,"n_neither":1641,"pe":0.49305766252644256,"po":0.22457942533869288},"ooni|voidly_probes":{"kappa":-0.09157168296763658,"n":13434,"n_a_only":5582,"n_b_only":896,"n_both_present":200,"n_neither":6756,"pe":0.5582431028938304,"po":0.5177906803632574}},"per_source_marginals":{"censoredplanet":{"n_present":3052,"rate":0.22718475509900254},"ioda":{"n_present":7387,"rate":0.5498734554116421},"ooni":{"n_present":5782,"rate":0.43040047640315615},"voidly_probes":{"n_present":1096,"rate":0.08158404049426828}},"sources":["ooni","ioda","censoredplanet","voidly_probes"]},"country":"IR","generated_at":"2026-10-04T05:15:07.039559Z","honest_caveats":["Source-presence is binary at the country-day level (one row -> present), so a single elevated OONI test counts the same as a dozen IODA outage rows. This avoids letting one noisy source dominate the agreement rate.","Voidly and Voidly-Community are merged into a single voidly_probes bucket -- their coverage overlaps geographically.","Cohen's kappa is computed over country-days WHERE AT LEAST ONE SOURCE FIRED. Days where no source fired are excluded so kappa isn't inflated by trivial 'both quiet' agreement across 200+ countries.","Most pairwise kappas are LOW (0.05-0.20). This is the honest finding -- the four sources observe DIFFERENT layers of the internet (active probing vs BGP vs DNS scans vs reachability checks) and rarely happen to fire on the same country-day. Low kappa here doesn't mean the sources are wrong; it means they're complementary, which is exactly why multi-source corroboration is informative when it DOES happen.","IODA fires heavily on connectivity disruptions that are not censorship (fiber cuts, BGP misconfigs). This is why the forecast pipeline excludes IODA from confirmed-censorship labels -- but we still report IODA presence here, because the journalist's question 'did multiple sources see this?' is answered by what they observed, not by our label rules."],"n_country_days":248,"n_country_days_with_2plus_sources":173,"ok":true,"schema":"voidly-cross-source-agreement-country/v1","timeline":[{"date":"2026-10-03","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-10-02","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-10-01","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-30","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-29","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-28","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-27","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-26","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-25","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-24","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-23","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-22","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-21","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-20","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-19","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-18","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-17","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-16","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-15","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-14","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-13","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-12","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-11","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-10","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-09","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-08","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-07","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-06","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-05","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-04","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-03","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-02","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-09-01","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-31","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-30","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-29","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-28","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-27","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-26","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-25","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-24","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-23","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-22","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-21","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-20","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-19","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-18","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-17","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-16","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-15","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-14","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-13","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-12","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-11","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-10","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-09","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-08","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-07","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-06","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-05","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-04","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-03","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-02","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-08-01","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-31","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-30","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-29","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-28","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-27","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-26","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-25","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-24","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-23","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-22","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-21","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-20","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-19","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-18","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-17","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-16","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-15","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-14","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-13","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-12","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-11","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-10","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-09","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-08","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-07","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-06","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-05","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-04","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-03","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-02","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-07-01","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-30","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-29","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-28","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-27","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-26","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-25","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-24","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-23","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-22","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-21","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-20","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-19","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-18","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-17","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-16","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-15","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-14","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-13","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-12","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-11","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-10","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-09","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-08","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-07","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-06","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-05","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-04","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-03","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-02","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-06-01","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-31","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-30","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-29","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-28","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-27","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-26","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-25","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-24","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-23","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-22","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-21","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-20","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-19","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-18","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-17","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-16","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-15","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-14","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-13","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-12","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-11","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-10","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-09","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-08","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-07","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-06","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-05","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-04","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-03","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-02","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-05-01","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-30","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-29","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-28","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-27","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-26","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-25","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-24","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-23","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-22","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-21","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-20","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-19","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-18","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-17","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-16","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-15","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-14","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-13","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-12","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-11","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-04-10","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-04-09","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-04-08","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-04-07","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-04-06","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-04-04","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-04-01","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-03-31","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-03-30","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-29","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-28","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-27","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-26","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-25","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-24","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-23","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-22","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-21","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-20","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-19","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-18","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-17","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-16","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-15","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-14","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-13","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-12","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-11","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-10","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-09","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-08","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-07","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-06","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-05","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-04","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-03","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-02","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-03-01","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-28","n_sources":2,"sources":["ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-27","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-26","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-25","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-24","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-23","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-22","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-21","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-20","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-19","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-18","n_sources":3,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-17","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-16","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-15","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-14","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-13","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-12","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-11","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-10","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-09","n_sources":1,"sources":["ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-08","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ooni"]},{"date":"2026-02-05","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda"]},{"date":"2026-02-04","n_sources":1,"sources":["censoredplanet"]},{"date":"2026-02-03","n_sources":2,"sources":["censoredplanet","ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-18","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-17","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-15","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-13","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-12","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-11","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-09","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-08","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-07","n_sources":1,"sources":["ioda"]},{"date":"2026-01-01","n_sources":1,"sources":["censoredplanet"]}],"window_days":365}